Digital Outback Photo
- Photography using Digital SLRs

The Art of Raw Conversion #017

 

Adobe DNG: Digital Negative Format

preview note by Uwe Steinmueller (9/27/2004)

 
 
November 2004 "Digital Fine Art Photographer's Summit" in Phoenix, AZ
 
See also Adobe press release (DNG, ACR 2.3)
 

With digital images we face and interesting dilemma:

  • Images can last forever as they are only data
  • They can even improve over time as image processing will evolve
  • Data loss is a big issue (backup, backup, backup)

This is challenging enough. But there is more:

  • Will be interesting how many file types we may able to read in 10 let alone 100 years.

Over the last four years we have seen endless new raw formats in the market as every vendor uses his own format. This does not only make the life of third party raw converter vendors more difficult but will even challenge the vendors themselves to support their own legacy.

The different raw formats are not different because the real raw data have that many variations. The main reasons are:

  • Different compression schema (both lossless and lossy)
  • Different and even secret metadata (data about the image data)
  • Protect the data to be used by third party raw converters. This leaves the big question: Does the vendor own the data or we the users. We feel bad about vendors that want to prevent us from using other third party raw converters. We think we as the users own the data once they are on our CF cards and can do with them whatever we like.

This means that with every new raw format all(!) raw converter vendors have to do the following:

  • Decipher the raw file format
    • Which format?
    • Which compression?
    • Where are these metadata?
    • What do the metadata mean?

This by itself leads to the question: why is there no standard way to store raw image data?

Adobe DNG: Digital Negative Format

Over the last 18 month Adobe Camera Raw (ACR) has become a major tool for opening raw files of any kind. As of now ACR opens nearly every raw file in the market (some digital back raw files excluded). During this process Thomas Knoll (creator of Photoshop and ACR) came across all the existing variations of raw file formats and was able to distill their common structure. As a result Adobe presents now the public DNG specification. This is intended to be an open standard that will evolve as the digital imaging will also improve.

The main goal of this standard is clearly to encourage all camera vendors to use DNG in their future cameras. But also for us users this tool is appealing as we can start storing raw data in this new format with the hope that it will be longer readable than vendor specific formats. But of course this makes only sense if raw converter vendors also start to support DNG. Only time will tell.

Some simple details about DNG

  • DNG is a TIFF file variant
  • Data can be stored compressed or lossless compressed (of course it cannot fix anything if the original raw format was already lossy compressed)
  • DNG metadata that describe the raw data and are derived from the original vendor data
    • There is even a tag: DNGPrivateData that allows vendors to store private data in DNG without disclosing their content(*).
  • For more details please check out the standard specification itself

(*) Why is this needed? There can be situations where a vendor may use a secret technique in his camera and want to protect this intellectual property.

There is one interesting technical aspect of DNG that maybe used for tools in the future. The image data can be stored in two forms:

  • Native raw data
  • Linear data (these are already demosaiced)

This allows the following (at least in theory)

  • Use one raw converter to de-mosaic the raw data
  • Use tools that work on the linear data (e.g. noise tools)
  • Then perform all the other operations (gamma, tone curve, color, ...) with the same raw converter or even a different one.

Camera Raw implements DNG

To no surprise the latest version of ACR all support DNG (ACR 2.3 and also the version in PS Elements 3). We feel that this puts some pressure on other raw converter vendors to also support DNG. Fortunately they may only need to implement ar DNG reader as Adobe delivers a free DNG converter.

Digital Negative Converter

The DNG Converter is a very simple (and we think also pretty fast) batch converter tool.

1. Select an input folder with any raw files (all other formats will be ignored)

2. Select an output folder

3. Perform some basic renaming (e.g. prefix all files with "dng_")

4. Set preferences:

  • Compression yes/no
  • Keep raw data or perform basic demosaicing which results in so called linear data.

Conclusion

Some will claim that Adobe only wants to further strengthen their role in the raw converter business. This is probably true and just normal in business. But we also feel that Adobe made the needed step towards a standard raw format.

We hope that some of the vendors finally give up inventing new raw formats and implement DNG based raw formats for their cameras. DNG is public and looks open to us.

Overall we will help to support DNG as for us it is a step into the right direction.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   

For Comments post in our News Group

2000-2004 Digital Outback Photo