Digital Outback Photo
- Photography using Digital SLRs


 

Printing Insights #032

HP Photosmart 8450 Experience Report



A review diary by Uwe Steinmueller

 
 
 
The diary always has the latest entry on top
 

 
9/4/2005 HP Photosmart 8750 Professional Diary started
 
We use now a HP 8750 for our portfolio proof prints.
 

 
2/19/2005 HP Photosmart 8750 Professional Photo Printer announced
 

Today at PMA 2005 the big brother HP Photosmart 8750 Professional Photo Printer was announced (prints up to 13x19").

The 8750 also features new improved ink cartridges for HP 102 Gray (B/W prints) and HP 101 for better nature blue rendering. Download the HP fact sheet from here.

 

 
2/18/2005 First Impressions
 

We recently started our rview diary about the HP Designjet 30/130. Like its big brother (the 8450 only prints up tp letter size) the HP Photosmart 8450 claims (actually backed up by Wilhelm Imaging Research) longevity on HP Photo Plus Glossy and Soft Gloss papers. We have no intention to check this printer with any matte papers as we wind the HP printers are at their best with glossy media.

Note: we are only interested in the HP 8450 as a fine art proofing printer and won't bother about all the other features like print direct from a CF card. Actually this printer is especially interesting for its B/W capabilities.

The 8450 is unique that is can use 4 different cartridges for its 3 head slots (for the HP 8450 the ink cartridges also include the heads - unlike the HP Designjet 30/130):

  • HP 97 Tri-color (3 colors)
  • HP 99 Photo (3 colors)
  • HP 96 Black (1 black)
  • HP 100 Gray Photo (3 gray/black)

At any time you have 3 cartridges in the printer if you plan to make photo prints:

As shown above the one not used cartridge can be parked in a special place above the heads. The black and gray cartridges can be switched at any time (not sure how much ink you lose during that process). If you enter a new cartridge the printer will calibrate itself using a sheet of plain paper.

This setup allows a flexibilty to print color and B/W on the 8450:

a) HP 97, 99, 100: B/W prints using the gray inks or color

b) HP 97, 99, 96: Color prints

Print Quality

B/W

The B/W prints on Photo Plus Glossy paper with the gray ink cartridge are very good if you use the grayscale mode in the driver (see screen shot below).


Setting the driver to B/W

Very good is the fact that the source images can be in AdobeRGB and the printer will honor this setting. This way your preview in Photoshop will be close to what you get from the 8450.

You don't have any control on the print toning. This would not bother us because the B/W tone is very nice.

Note: The documentation we got was really poor. There was no mentioning how to properly print a B/W image. Under B/W we found only how to install the Gray cartridge.

Color

Color prints on Photo Plus Glossy paper are not bad either. But here the profiles delivered by HP seem to be a bit limited as there is no direct support for the Soft Gloss papers (we got pretty over saturated prints on that paper).

Cost

The HP 8450 is cheap at about $250. But the real cost will be invested into paper and inks. The ink cartridges are tiny and have the following extra cost factors:

  • Most cartridges have three inks. The cartridge has to be replaced if one of the inks is gone (actually the printer will warn too early to replace the cartridge and not find out that only one ink is out (a wasted print will show a missing color or gray).
  • Each cartridge has a new head. This avoids clogging with old heads but also adds to the cost.

The HP Photo Plus paper is at the same price level as other highend glossy papers.

Overall the ink cost will be significant if you print a lot.

Quirks

We had sometimes the problem that we incidentally hit the print button. Then the next time we booted up Windows the printer was using 3(!) sheets of paper and printed one line of garbled text on them. We think the printer should reset if the PC boots up.

Solution: keep the per off the tray when you shut down the printer.

 

 

 

 
 

 

For Comments post in our News Group

2000-2007 Digital Outback Photo